Karl’s Mystery Tackle Box Subscription Review

mystery tackle box webpage screenshot

Mystery Tackle Box (MTB) is a monthly fishing subscription box offering a variety of lures, bait, and tackle. Every shipment includes exclusive fishing gear, a handful of paired lures and tackle, and a tutorial booklet to help you hone your angling skills. Subscribers can expect to save up to 40% off the combined MSRP of the items compared to retail prices. Deliveries ship for free on the 1st of each month.


How Mystery Tackle Box Works

MTB is loaded with exclusive gear and new products to help you become a better angler. No matter your level of experience, you will find something that will improve your fishing game in every monthly box.

Here is an overview of how the fishing subscription service works: 

Pick Your Subscription Plan

The first thing you need to do is heading over to the company's website (or, just click the subscribe button above) and navigate to their "Plans" page.

You can choose from their RegularPro, or Elite subscription plans, which are described in detail further down this page. 

Within each plan, you have the option of choosing the species of fish that you want to catch. Options include Bass, Trout, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish, Catfish, and Walleye. Subscribers can change their species selection each month if needed. 

The Pro and Elite plans offer a "multi-species" option, which is suitable for Bass, Panfish, and Catfish.

There is a seasonal Ice Fishing option for the colder months as well.

Finally, select your plan duration. Choose from monthly, 3-month, 6-month, and 12-month shipments.  

If you've never been fishing before, you can opt for the Beginner Series plan. This includes basic bass and panfish tackle, as well as technique tutorials and tips from expert fishermen. The "Learn to Fish" Beginner Series is available in a single 3-month plan.

Add To Cart and Checkout 

Click the "Add to Cart" button once you have decided on your plan, species, and plan duration.  

On the next page, enter your email address if you're a new customer. If you're a returning customer, the website will ask you to login to your existing account. 

Enter your shipping details and payment method before reviewing your order to ensure everything is correct. 

Shipping is always free, so you'll only be paying for the cost of your plan.

Receive Your Delivery (#HAPPYDANCE)

Your first shipment will be sent out within 10 days from when you placed your order. Subsequent shipments will be mailed out within the first 10 days of each month. 

Once you receive your delivery, it's time to dig into your box and have some fun!

What Makes Mystery Tackle Box Unique?

Mystery Tackle Box stands out from the crowd by including over one hundred fishing gear brands in their boxes. 

Plus, this fishing subscription box separates itself from its competition by always throwing in plenty of soft bait samples and worm hooks which other boxes tend to skimp out on with their deliveries.

Best of all, subscribers earn great discounts on the many items in Karl’s Bait & Tackle online store.


  • Ability to switch species selection each month
  • Species-specific boxes
  • An average of 33% savings compared to retail
  • check
    Free Shipping
  • check
    Discounts at Karl's Bait & Tackle


  • Not enough species to choose from
  • Tutorials and Tips are rudimentary
  • Not enough terminal tackle 

Pricing & What’s Included

The outdoor subscription box for fishermen is available in four distinct subscription plans: Regular, Pro, Elite, and Beginner’s Series.

MTB box has recruited the help of expert tournament fishermen to help them curate the items that end up in each monthly delivery. 

Subscribers will receive a variety of fishing products from both well-known and up-and-coming manufacturers. The company states that their goal is to vary the contents enough so that you can try things that you've heard about before and provide you with guidance on how to use them.  

These aren't just sample-size products, either. You'll get a mix of full-size hard baits as well as a variety of smaller samples. 

Each Mystery Tackle Box typically includes: 

  • Lures and Tackle
  • Limited Edition Fishing Gear
  • "How-To" Videos from Experts
  • Various Perks for Members

Multiple versions of each box are sent out each month, ensuring that you'll never receive the same box more than once. 

Each of the four packages is offered at varying price points and include different items. Shipping within North America is free.

MTB Regular

The Regular plan includes species options for Bass, Trout, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish, Catfish, and Walleye. 

The included contents should add up to about $25.00 in value.


  • Monthly Cost: $16.99 per month
  • 3-Month Plan Cost: $14.99 per month
  • 6-Month Plan Cost: $14.99 per month
  • check
    12-Month Plan Cost: $13.99 per month


The Pro plan includes species options for Bass, Multi-Species, Trout, Inshore Saltwater, Panfish, and Walleye. 

The included contents should add up to about $40.00 in value.


  • Monthly Cost: $26.99 per month
  • 3-Month Plan Cost: $24.49 per month
  • 6-Month Plan Cost: $24.49 per month
  • 12-Month Plan Cost: $23.49 per month

MTB Elite

The Elite plan is comprised of premium Bass fishing gear only.

The included contents should add up to about $60.00 in value.


  • Monthly Cost: $39.99 per month
  • 3-Month Plan Cost: $36.99 per month
  • 6-Month Plan Cost: $36.99 per month
  • check
    12-Month Plan Cost: $34.99 per month

Beginners Series

The "Learn to Fish" Beginners Series is a 3-box subscription that costs $59.97. 

It includes all the gear and tutorials you need to get started with fishing. 

Here's what you get in each of the 3 beginner boxes:

  • Month 1: Tackle, fishing line, basic knots and reel tips, fishing safety information.
  • Month 2: Hard baits, how to set a hook, the best time and place to fish
  • Month 3: Crankbait, spinnerbait, and swim bait; Texas rig intro; how to read the water

MTB Gift Certificates are available for all plans for those of you that want to surprise the fisherman in your life! Just navigate to the "Gifts" page on the website, choose your plan, and print the gift certificate. The recipient will be able to redeem them on the website. 

Mystery Tackle Box Reviews

There are many Mystery Tackle Box reviews floating around online, and we checked out each of them to get a feel for what the fishing and subscription box community thinks of this company. Generally, public opinion of this company is positive.

On Trustpilot, Mystery Tackle Box has a TrustScore of 9.1 out of 10. Their rank of “Excellent” is aggregated from over 5,000 verified customer reviews.

While many customers praised the company’s inclusion of high-quality equipment, some panned the Elite package for featuring much of the same gear found in lesser subscription tiers.

Many of the MTB reviews we read online discussed how most of the time subscription boxes provided plenty of in-demand gear and exclusive items. However, we also noticed a vocal minority that complained about their poor and untimely customer service voicemail and their lack of hooks included in the Regular subscription boxes.

Here's a detailed MTB video review from RhinoFishing TV:

Mystery Tackle Box Review - May 2019

We are subscribed to the Regular plan and received our very first delivery in May 2019. 

Here's a look at what we received:

Mystery Tackle Box May 2019 Review

Our delivery included the following products:

  • Mustad Big Eye Bucktail Jig
  • BioSpawn EXOSWIM 4” Swimbait
  • Harmony Razor Series EWG Hooks - Size 4/0 (5 Pack - Bait Pegs Included)
  • Strike Pro Tournament Grade Gill Raker Sinking Lure
  • Penetration “F” Hook - 5” Fluke Hooks (2 Pack - Size 4/0)

Being that it was the first delivery we received from the company, we didn't have much to compare it against. 

We liked the nice selection of lures and worm hooks that we received. It also appears that the contents were selected based on the time of year, which we thought was a really nice touch.

Read our detailed review of the May 2019 delivery for more information about each of the included fishing products. 

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some common questions people ask about Mystery Tackle Box.

How Do I Change My Box Type to a Different Species?

Changing your box type to a new species is a simple process. All you have to do is sign into your account and select “SWITCH” from your account dashboard. From there, choose your desired species and click “CHANGE SPECIES.” 

This needs to be done by the last day of the month for you to get the new species box with your next shipment.

How Do I Contact Customer Service?

Their customer service support team can be reached via email at  support@mysterytacklebox.com.

When Do The Boxes Ship?

All subscription boxes ship out within 10 business days from when your order is paid and processed. All subsequent boxes ship within the first ten days of each month.

How Long Does It Usually Take to Receive My Box?

All boxes ship via UPS and final deliveries are carried out by the United States Postal Services (USPS). It can take up to 5 to 7 business days to arrive in the continental United States and several days longer for Canadian, Alaskan, Hawaiian, and Puerto Rican subscribers.

How Do I Stop My Subscription?

Ending your subscription is managed by signing into your account and selecting “More Options” from the dashboard. From there, select the “Stop This Subscription” link.  

How Do I Return or Exchange My Order?

MTB subscriptions are nonrefundable and are not eligible for any type of exchange. The company holds a firm stance in regards to this policy. 

Company History

This fishing subscription box is owned and operated by Karl’s Bait and Tackle, a Chicago-based company only a few blocks away from beautiful Lake Michigan. The company grew out of the founder’s frustration with the amount of time and money they spent trying out tackle and experimenting with new techniques—they knew there had to be a better way to learn.

Founded in 2012 by entrepreneur Ross Gordon after graduating from the creative writing program at Yeshiva University, MTB has become the leading subscription company in the fishing space. In recent years, Gordon has gone on to found BioSpawn Lure Company, a business which manufactures premium fishing lures.   

Today, MTB is headed by veteran angler and Chief Fishing Officer (CFO) Karl VonDibble who doubles as a brand spokesperson. VonDibble and his full-time staff of over 25 employees at Karl’s Bait and Tackle continue Gordon’s vision to provide quality fishing and angling gear for beginners, enthusiasts, and professionals alike.

So... Is Mystery Tackle Box Worth It? 

When you subscribe to MTB, you're getting insane value compared to what you would pay for these items individually at the store. The company is backed by a FREAKIN' BAIT & TACKLE STORE, so you know that you're getting tackle and lures that actual fisherman would use.

They even make it easy for you to get started in case this is your first time. The Beginner's Series is AWESOME. 

So, yes, it's worth it!

Interested in this crate?Learn more & get your box today!

You May Also Enjoy: