Menlo Club Review: Subscription Boxes for Menswear, Footwear, and Athleisure Style

menlo club review

Menlo Club is an online men’s membership program that provides curated monthly clothing items like Five Four, New Republic, and Grand AC. Each month, you will receive an average of 2-3 pieces per month, varying between contemporary menswear, footwear, and athletic leisure garments. Within each package, you are getting $120 worth of items from the Menlo Club seasonal collection for $60. Boxes are usually shipped 7-10 days after the charge date and arrive within 2-5 days of the shipping date.


How It Works

The subscription box is designed for men on a budget who want to build up their wardrobe. The clothes are picked out for the casual man who likes to dress for the weekend.

Over 12 months, members will receive New Republic footwear, Grand AC athleisure clothing, and Five Four contemporary wear. As a part of the club, you also unlock the power of member-only pricing at the e-commerce store Menlo House and other perks, including various promotions.

The signup process is simple and straightforward. When you get to the homepage, click on the orange “get started” button toward the top right. You will then fill out a short style quiz. Here, you give information about your style, fit, and sizes to help the company pick out the right clothes for your monthly package.

You will have the option to select a mix, casual, or forward style. You then choose either a monthly subscription (delivered every month) or a seasonal one (every three months). The website will ask you about your top size and shoe size to complete the quiz.

After putting in your payment information and joining the club, you will then be set to receive your first package within the next 1-2 weeks.

What Makes Menlo Club Unique?

For anyone who is looking to gradually upgrade the wardrobe without putting a massive dent in the wallet, Menlo Club is a great option. You will get great value for your package by paying $60 for 2-3 items that are usually worth $120 at the retail level. These are also brands that are trusted and established. You accomplish all of these benefits without having to spend time shopping at the store each month.

You end up with a style that is unique to your preference, and the quiz is in-depth when asking you the preliminary questions. The support team is also very responsive and is quick to get back with you for a size or style change.

What We Like

  • Trusted brands included, like New Republic, Five Four, and Grand AC
  • Ongoing discounts, promotional opportunities, and free shipping if you are a Menlo Club member
  • Quality design backed by an award-winning fashion designer
  • check
    Affordable, exclusive menswear in professional-casual styles for younger men

What Could Be Better

  • The quantity of different brands offered is limited compared to other subscription services
  • No return policy of clothes that you do not like
  • No personal stylist – the process is thorough but algorithm-based
  • check
    Limited tiers of packages

Pricing & What’s Included

All members receive the same collection of brands for the year, and the same quantity of items on a month to month basis. But there are a few subscription options that you can choose from if you want to alter your delivery frequency.

  • Monthly subscription ($60 every month) – will receive 2-3 items per month
  • Seasons subscription ($75 every three months) – will receive 2-3 items every three months

Over 12 months, members will receive:

  • New Republic footwear in two chosen months
  • Grand AC athleisure wear in two other months
  • Five Four contemporary wear in the remaining eight months.

Club members also receive 25% off items in the Menlo House e-commerce store, including free shipping on all orders. Everyone also gains access to member-only items and flash sales.

Menlo Club Reviews

Based on reviews from Ask Men, Menlo Club received a rating of 4.5 out of 5 stars. Based on what consumers are saying, they are impressed at the price you pay compared to the retail value. There there is not a wide array of brands included in the subscription service. But the quality you are getting is excellent for what the budget-friendly young man is looking to achieve.

Certain people think the company could do better with its branding and packaging, along with the need for more subscription options. But overall, a majority of the reviews agree that you are getting a great deal with Menlo Club.

Here's a review from BoomFitnessJourney: 

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are the common questions that people ask about Menlo Club.

How Can I Cancel My Subscription?

Members can cancel the subscription by calling in at (888) 341-2381, Monday through Friday, from 9 A.M. to 5 P.M. PST. There is also a live chat available for people between 8 A.M. and 5 P.M. PST to update their member status. But for security reasons, a cancellation can only be processed once a member has spoken to a member experience representative.

You are permitted to cancel the membership at any time, but to avoid being charged for the next month, cancellations must occur before the 14th of the month.

How Can I Contact Customer Service?

Menlo Club's customer service can be reached at 

When Does it Ship Every Month?

As soon as you submit an order, packages are shipped usually 7-10 days after that. Depending on your location, packages can arrive between 2-5 days of the shipping date.

You will also get charged as soon as you submit the order, and then charged the 15th of every month after that.

Can I Return My Items?

No, returns on Menlo Club packages are not allowed. The company claims that each item is curated for your style, profile, and sizes, based on your style, although size changes are permitted by contacting customer service.

What If I Want to Change My Style Profile or Sizes?

You can complete this by logging in to your account and accessing your member dashboard. There, you can make adjustments to your profile and sizes. You can also email a member of the service team to apply these changes.

Company History

Menlo Club got formed as a subscription service extension of the Five Four Group, a holding company for fashion brands and services. Dee Murthy and Andres Izquieta, two students from the University of Southern California, became best friends at a house on Menlo Avenue (influencing the name). They wanted to create a brand that represents their lifestyle and beliefs: a brand that challenges the rules and systems.

Started in 2002, the company held brands like Five Four, Young & Reckless, New Republic, Grand AC, Oshenta, Ales Grey, Club Fantasy, and Midnight Studios. At first, the company was contingent on the department stores because the traditional retail model was the first option for final consumers. As they continued to evolve with the market, they revamped Five Four and took everything online. Their goal is to help people look stylish with minimal effort.

Today, the original founders operate the Menlo House and Club, making fashion simple, secure, and approachable. The company also partnered up with award-winning New York designer Mark McNairy, who leads the design team. The company headquarters is located in Los Angeles, California.

Interested in this crate?Learn more & get your box today!

You May Also Enjoy: