Hunt A Killer Review - Murder Mystery Subscription Box

hunt a killer review

Hunt A Killer is a subscription box that brings you a new murder mystery to solve each month. Each delivery, or episode, contains a new piece of a murder mystery with clues for you to solve. Members can expect to save anywhere from about 15 to 50 percent compared to other mystery kits. The first box ships the same day of order placement and new boxes ship on the 22nd of each month.


How It Works

This murder mystery subscription box is great for any detective who’s looking for a fun and immersive mystery to solve. Each month, you’ll receive another piece of a 6 episode puzzle. Every box contains new clues like evidence, witness statements, and more, and includes a detective’s notebook to keep all your findings in order. There are 6 episodes per season, and once you’re finished, you can move onto the next mystery!

To sign up, head to their website and select See If You Qualify on their homepage. From there, you’ll take a quick survey that asks questions about how easily scared you are and who you plan to play the game with (if anyone).

From there, you can decide between a Month-to-Month, Season Pass (6-Month), or Double Season (12-Month) membership. You’ll get the same amount of stuff per box no matter which one you choose, so it depends more on how long you want to play.

Once you’ve chosen your package, fill in your billing and shipping information, and wait for your first murder mystery box to arrive!

What Makes Hunt A Killer Unique?

Hunt A Killer is developed and put together by skilled true crime writers. They create settings, characters, and evidence to fully immerse you in the experience of being a murder detective. Each box, or episode, is part of a larger mystery, and over the course of 6 months, you’ll receive new clues until you reach the end of the season.

You have the option to stop there or continue with a new series of episodes. If you want, there’s even an option to buy the whole season at once so you don’t have to wait a whole month for the next box. You can also request early shipping if you finish solving the mystery before the next box ships.


  • Can play alone or with family and friends
  • In-depth stories and details for hours of solving
  • More than one mystery to solve
  • check
    Written by true crime pros
  • check
    Ships internationally
  • check
    Can request early shipping or purchase all at once


  • Contents are the same with each membership level
  • Limited options for mysteries

Pricing & What’s Included

Although each subscription package contains the same mysteries, there are a few different options for how you can receive the boxes and how many seasons you can sign up for. The more you sign up for, the more murders you can solve, each over a 6 month period. You can choose from these subscription options:


This box is the most expensive at $30 per month. It’s also the easiest to pause or cancel if you find you don’t have time to solve the mysteries every month.

Season Pass (6-Month)

This is the most popular option at $27.95 per month. It gives you a full 6 months of mystery boxes so you can complete a full season. You save 8 percent compared to the Month-to-Month version, and you get free shipping within the US.

Double Season Pass (12-Month)

This box costs $25 per month, which makes it the cheapest option overall. You save 17 percent off the Month-to-Month boxes and you get free US shipping. This box gives you two full seasons of mysteries, so once you finish the first 6 episodes, you’ll get a new murder to solve.

Premium Cases

This is the best option if you don’t want to wait to receive new episodes each month. This option varies depending on which Premium Case you choose. The cheapest one is $99 while the most expensive is $250. With Premium Cases, you’ll receive all the materials for a full season of one mystery.

Hunt A Killer Reviews

We found tons of Hunt A Killer reviews, and they were overwhelmingly positive. The subscription has a 9.0 out of 10 rating on TrustPilot. The average rating out of almost 1900 reviews is 5 stars.

Most customers seem to enjoy playing the game with friends and family, but others say it’s just as much fun to play alone. One reviewer was impressed with how “high-quality, detailed, and well-strategized” the game is while others rave about its design and organization. Many Hunt A Killer reviews also talk about how immersive the game is. Some say it took them 30 minutes to solve the mystery while others take several hours.

We looked around to see if there was anything negative you should know, too. Hunt A Killer reviews on Better Business Bureau state that some people had trouble getting refunded for subscriptions they wanted to cancel while others were not aware of the automatic subscription renewal. The company responded to every complaint and in almost every case was able to issue refunds or otherwise correct any problems.

Aside from these few instances, people really seemed to enjoy their subscriptions and most recommended the box for game nights and gatherings.

Here's a video review from Gabulosis: 

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are some common questions and answers about Hunt A Killer: 

How Can I Contact Customer Service?

You can contact customer service by email at

When Does It Ship Every Month?

Each box ships on the 22nd of each month. However, you have the option to request early shipping if you don’t want to wait a full month for delivery.

Can I Buy It As A Gift?

Yes! You can purchase a Premium Case or a membership for a friend or family member. Just enter their shipping information into appropriate fields at checkout. That way, their box will ship directly to them.

How Long Does It Take To Solve A Box?

This varies from person to person. Some people take a couple of hours while others can spend all day on one episode. It depends how far you want to go to investigate the case and solve the mystery. People who want to get really into it can dig deep into the clues and find details that some might miss.

Company History

Hunt A Killer was founded in 2016 by Ryan Hogan and Derrick Smith, whose friendship goes all the way back to middle school.

At first, it was a once a year event at Camp Ramblewood in Maryland, but the co-founders soon realized they had to expand their reach if they wanted to make an impact in entertainment. The subscription service has gained tens of thousands of members in just 3 years, and the founders see only growth in its future.

This unique subscription service has been featured in popular publications like Washington Post and Bustle. A portion of the earnings from the subscription boxes goes to the Cold Case Foundation, which helps solve real cases.

You can watch a trailer to see what’s inside one of their Premium Cases here:

Interested in this crate?Learn more & get your box today!

You May Also Enjoy: