Bullymake Box Review - Power Chewer Toy Subscription Box for Dogs

bullymake homepage

Bullymake is a durable toy subscription box specifically for dogs that are “power chewers.” Each monthly box contains two to three durable toys, three to four chews and treats, and other goods based on each dog’s weight and allergies. You can expect to save nearly half the cost of retail. Boxes arrive every 30 days, though there’s no shipment on weekends.


How It Works

This animal subscription box is exclusively for dogs, but it’s also specifically tailored to “bully breed” dogs. In general, that means dogs who are “power chewers” and tend to destroy softer and less durable toys.

Each month’s delivery includes a selection of chew toys, treats, and other goods. Every item is meant to be long-lasting and withstand plenty of playing and chewing by bigger dogs. There’s also an option to forgo the food items and only include toys.

To sign up, you’ll click on the subscription length option you want on the home page of the website. Options are 1 Month, 3 Months, 6 Months, and 12 Months. Clicking on an option takes you to a signup page.

On this page, you can select one or more boxes, then click on “BUY ME!” to continue to the payment page. You have an option to add a premium toy for $9 more per month, and you can answer either “YES, PLEASE!” or “NO, THANKS.” Answering this question takes you to the next page of the process.

The final page requires your billing and shipping information to complete the purchase. You’ll also need to enter any allergies that your pet has from the dropdown menu. Options for allergies include:

  • No Known Allergies
  • Grain Allergy
  • Chicken & Grain Allergy
  • check
    Beef & Grain Allergy
  • check
    Toys Only

Finally, select your pet’s weight from the drop-down menu. The company caters to dogs from 10 to 200 pounds. If you’re shopping for a puppy, you can adjust your dog’s weight from your account dashboard later on as he or she grows.

Remember to click “BUY NOW!” once you fill all the fields, and your order will be complete! Your order will ship the next business day, and you’ll receive a tracking number as soon as it ships.

What Makes Bullymake Box Unique?

Bullymake is unique in that they address a specific need of pet owners with larger or more rambunctious dogs. For pets that tend to rip apart plush toys or bite pieces off toys, this subscription will hopefully change playtime for the better.

The company focuses on power chewers and accommodates dogs from 10 to 200 pounds, plus dogs with allergies. They also maintain a 100% Guarantee on their toys. That means they’ll replace any toy that your dog destroys within 14 days of shipment.

While standard boxes include treats and toys, there’s also an alternate option for toys only. All Bullymake toys and treats are designed, sourced, and manufactured in the USA. Their online store also stocks all the toys from the subscription boxes, though you’ll be paying retail prices when shopping directly from the store as opposed to the higher-value subscription option.

Overall, the company has tested its toys on breeds like:

  • Pit Bulls
  • Bulldogs
  • Great Danes
  • check
  • check
    Golden Retrievers
  • check
  • Boxers
  • Cane Corso
  • Rottweiler
  • check
    American Staffordshire Terrier
  • check
  • check
    Boston Terriers

Do note, no boxes include rawhide, as the company deems it dangerous for dogs. Packages also leave out plush toys since most aggressive chewers will only destroy them!

What We Like

  • Free shipping in the US
  • 100% Guarantee on toys
  • Allergy options
  • check
    Toy-only box options
  • check
    Rawhide-free for pet safety
  • check
    Online store stocks toys from the boxes so you can buy more

What Could Be Better

  • Shipping to Canada is $8, global shipping is more

Pricing & What’s Included

There are four subscription lengths and pricing options with this bully breed box. Each subscription box contains the same items to make a total of five to six premium items.


  • 1 Month: $39.00 per box
  • 3 Month: $36.00 per box
  • 6 Month: $34.00 per box
  • check
    12 Month: $31 per box

What's Included

  • 2 to 3 durable toys
  • check
    3 to 4 treats, chews, & healthy edibles
  • check
    Hand-selected goods based on your dog's weight & allergies

For any level subscription, you can also add another premium toy for an additional $9 per month. Further, you can customize boxes based on your dog’s allergies (or lack thereof). If you opt to leave out the edibles and only receive toys, you’ll receive four items every month and no treats.

Once your box arrives, you have 14 days to request a replacement if an item is damaged, whether by your pet or via the shipping process. The company will determine whether the item qualifies for replacement based on a photo that you send to them.

Bullymake Box Reviews

The BBB has plenty of reviews and the company is accredited with the organization. From an average of over 700 consumer reviews, the company has an almost perfect rating out of five stars.

Five-star and similar reviews praise the durability of the dog toys and the fact that their pets seem to enjoy the monthly deliveries. They also appreciate the availability of allergy-friendly and toy-only box options.

In general, the one-star Bully make box review responses involve heavy chewers that were able to destroy the “indestructible” toys from one or more shipments. However, the majority of subscribers were satisfied with the overall quality and durability of the toys.

Other lower review comments note that it’s difficult to cancel a subscription, explaining that the only way to contact the company is either via email or chat function.

Here's a fun unboxing video from Ashleigh Emilia: 

Frequently Asked Questions

Here are answers to commonly asked questions about the Bully make box.

When Will It Ship?

Initial orders ship the next day, and subsequent orders ship 30 days later. However, boxes do not ship out on weekends. Therefore, the company tends to send orders early if the shipping date would otherwise fall on a weekend.

Can I Change My Delivery Frequency?

Yes, you can adjust your delivery and opt out of receiving monthly shipments. Just contact the company to alter your shipment frequency to your specifications.

How Do I Cancel My Subscription?

If you no longer want to receive a subscription, you can email or live chat with the company to cancel.

How Do I Contact Customer Service?

You can reach the company's customer service department via email at customercare@bullymake.com. 

My Dog Has Allergies, What Can I Do?

During the checkout process (and later in your account dashboard), you have the option to select an allergy status for your dog. Options range from “No Known Allergies” to chicken, beef, and grain allergies. There’s also an option for a toy-only box with no food products at all.

Company History

The Texas-based company is owned by Colin Hatzmann, who is both the CEO and an LLC member. He started the company in 2014 after attending Texas Tech University for Finance and Economics. Before starting the company, Colin was a Financial Examiner, putting his education to good use.

Originally, Colin wanted to market collars, leashes, and related items for bulldogs. But then he noticed his dog was destroying every toy he bought, inspiring him to cater to power chewing breeds with his new venture.

See the video below for details about monthly subscriptions from the company themselves!

Interested in this crate?Learn more & get your box today!

You May Also Enjoy: